Skip to main content

Never, Ever Invest in Solar

Never, EVER, invest in a large solar power system! NEVER!

Oh, feel free to spend a couple thousand dollars if playing with these gadgets turns you on. But I repeat, NEVER, EVER get caught up in the solar-social-justice-save-the-planet thing. A homestead needs lots and lots of tools and equipment, almost all of those can be bought for the price of a whopping solar system capable of truly powering an American family home as currently constructed. (Single men living in RV’s not included.)

Now, before the solarphiles jump down my throat: We visited a number of “solar powered, off-grid homesteads.” The dirty secret of these homesteads is propane/natural gas. They cooked with propane, they dried their clothes with propane, they heated the home with propane—and to be fair, with wood, but whenever I see a propane/natural gas furnace I get the sense that wood is used when convenient—and more importantly, they heated their domestic hot water with propane/natural gas. All of the big electricity draws of the house were powered by the detested “grid” (propane) as the practitioners took a bow for their "greenness." It was right out of a Monty Python skit. The one thing I do want to give them credit for was living without A.C. They were so close to walking the walk, it was just a bridge too far.

Most of them were trying crazy things they saw on Youtube to heat hot water—wrapping copper tubing around wood stove pipes (no one in their right mind fires the woodstove up in the house in warm weather) and contraptions for passive solar heating, that sort of thing—and failing miserably. Anyone can heat domestic hot water in the summer. A black barrel out in the sun works fine. (Somehow, water from the grid is OK; just not electric). It is another thing in cool and cold weather, especially on cloudy days. None of the people we visited seemed willing to tolerate the inconvenience of not having that hot water available under pressure (and using more electricity) at the taps in their homes.

Domestic hot water is literally half of a family’s electrical consumption (if they are not heating with electric). Over a lifetime, you could buy one of your children all of the material to build their house with the money you spend on the heating of domestic hot water.

A hot water kettle and a woodstove solve the heat, cooking, and hot water issue—provided you have access to cheap or inexpensive firewood. This is why I tell people that a woodlot is just as important as your garden or hay field on a homestead, but in the regions that make the most sense for homesteaders, there are usually large timber and sawmill operations. And they are always happy to get the tailings off of their property cheap.

A clothesline solves the dryer issue. It helps if you have a front porch to hang a clothesline for long stretches of rainy weather. In winter, a drying rack next to the woodstove works like a charm.

If you have access to grid power, I think it is better than solar power. Just don’t plug in an electric stove, clothes dryer, hot water heater, or HVAC system. Then wait for next month’s electric bill. When you see that it is only $35, you might lose interest in a $2,000 solar system. Or not. But at least you will be making a fully informed investment decision.

Here is a video of a family of seven living off-grid (click the link to see the video!). I communicated with them online when this video came out. Nice fellow. We study every single good idea we come in contact with. After looking at his solar array we decided that grid power was a better option. But if you don’t have access and you want internet and LED lights then this arrangement makes a lot of sense.

You will notice that they do it the same as we do. Hot water, cooking, heating, clothes drying is done without electricity. We use a generator for some tasks (like our 1941 Maytag) because we don’t have grid power in our workshops, barns, and outbuildings. (We just move a small, 4000-watt genny around). I imagine this family does something similar.

Anyway... I love REAL homesteaders doing it and raising a family. Enjoy.


Popular posts from this blog

Taking Action: The Home in Homesteading

A homestead is a home. This simple fact is overlooked by essentially all of the homesteading books, websites, and social media homesteading groups.

A homestead needs a real homemaker and she is the bedrock of her family and the home. The family needs a provider who does the heavy work around the homestead and brings in an income. This does not preclude the homemaker from actively bringing in an income, but it does preclude the homemaker from a 40-hour a week job and 10 hours per week commute. An individual leaving the home at 8am and returning at 6pm cannot possibly make a home or raise a family. No home and no family means no homestead. It means debt and wage slavery until you have accumulated enough assets to reach escape velocity—usually right about the age (and body weight) where you are no longer capable of doing anything. This is the corporate employment trap. I know it is harsh. Real life is like that.
Because, in reality, "homesteading" is merely the resettlement of …

When It's Real

In a real, cooperative, and interdependent community ("CIC"), a failure of one family causes great harm to all. When you rely on each other, a failure pulls everyone down, and it is for this reason that the successful CIC's have rules—and all of the failed communes and rebellious minded communities have long since circled the drain. Successful communities are comprised of people who bring something to the table, and the most important thing that they can bring is a future.

This is not to say that communities cannot be formed around an ethos other than religion. Secular cultural norms, ethics, and expectations could work just as well. The Quakers had incredibly successful communities—both economically and politically—while rejecting dogma and eschewing creeds of any kind. Emphasis on "had". The Quakers gave America and the world the ideas of Liberty and the sovereignty of the individual, and then most of their communities fell apart for reasons I shall discuss a…

The Economics of a Real Homestead

In the real world, there are facts—even in a world with a thousand shades of grey. These facts govern—and people who can accurately interpret the environment in which they find or place themselves in will have greater success and better outcomes than people who do not. The resettlement of the American countryside, what some people have taken to calling "homesteading," is governed by a set of environmental facts, and no amount of feel-good propaganda is going to have any impact on this set of facts.

This article is directed at people who have amassed hard-won resources and capital and are considering moving from the suburban model of living to the American countryside.

First, don't listen to the media. While it is true that most (there are plenty of wealthy landowners and businesses) of rural America is a disaster zone of government dependence, addiction, and obesity, disasters create opportunity. There are winners and losers in this environment, just as there is in urban…